« Daily Report for Wed, Nov 26, 2008 | Main | Daily Report for Thu, Nov 27, 2008 »

November 26, 2008

Is there an honest cop in Canada?:- The story of BCE

Why are the Canadian securities regulators and the financial editors turning a blind eye to the goings-on with the trading of BCE stock? Can’t they spot fraud when it’s sitting on the end of their noses? [Please see ADDENDUM]

I received the following mail on November 2, but was too busy to look into it.

Bill, You have likely read my comments regarding the BCE leveraged buy-out and why it highly unlikely to close. I think you could do a lot for your readers if you made a call on this and recommended a shorting or options strategy that would benefit the player who would profit by the sale not happening. It is incredible that media and HB&B are silent on this. Could it be that every broker has a ton of sheeple in their client base holding BCE and their prop traders are already lined up against their clients and stand to make a ton of money when the share price collapses?

I was assured there was another Stelco fraud going down. The mere thought of how much effort I put into disclosing that nasty bit of financial engineering by the Bay Street Bandits was enough to refocus my efforts on building a successful company here in The Bahamas.

Then I saw an item in the Discourse last night, which was followed by more mail:

Bill, Too bad there wasn’t enough time to get a report out on BCE. When the TSX price moved sharply from the low 30’s to the high 30’s late last Friday afternoon and early Monday I sensed that insiders were going to push this up and dump it this week before the KPMG fiasco went public. When I saw the 2M shares traded in AH trading and the WSJ article at 9:30 last night I knew what would happen this morning. I posted an alert on your blog @ 10:30 PM but was anyone listening? Regulators need to look at who did the 2M trade(s) last night and follow the money back to the insider. I guess $70M in trades last night is small potatoes to regulators (but not to the buyers of BCE over the last few days).

BCE.TO is now down over -33% on the day.

BCE happens to be by far the largest telephone and telecommunications company in Canada.

I noted the following news release hype leading into this collapse.

• CANADA STOCKS-TSX rises 4 per cent on resources, banksat Reuters(Mon, Nov 24)
The news about Citigroup, which is one of the banks financing BCE's (BCE.TO: Quote, Profile, Research, Stock Buzz) C$34.8 billion buyout, also helped lift BCE stock. [ID:nN24516514] BCE had languished as investors fretted the deal could be repriced, delayed or abandoned altogether because of problems in the financial markets. The stock climbed nearly 10 percent to C$37.83.
• Bell welcomes CRTC decision allowing wholesale Internet network managementCNW Group(Thu, Nov 20)
• Canada watchdog sides with BCE on Web traffic shapingat Reuters(Thu, Nov 20)
• Bell announces new smartphone plans offering 25 per cent more calling minutes than competitor plansCNW Group(Thu, Nov 20)
• VoIP Managed Service from Bell provides advanced toolkits, 24/7 expertiseCNW Group(Mon, Nov 17)
• Reuters Summit-UPDATE - TD Bank committed to financing BCEat Reuters(Wed, Nov 12)
• Reuters Summit-UPDATE - TD Bank committed to financing BCEat Reuters(Wed, Nov 12)

The parties who traded the BCE stock last night can be discovered in 15 minutes. If there was an honest cop in the country, insiders (and that includes bankers and lawyers) would be going to prison.

Do we need to resort to vigilante justice?

Oh Canada! What a sad state of affairs.


ADDENDUM

It is obvious to anyone who knows anything about Canada that there are good 'cops' in the country. I refer, of course, not just to the police and prosecutors, but to regulators, auditors, journalists and reporters, community activists, and all those who are engaged in what is called the checks and balances system of society. Most of these people, however, need to be alerted to serious problems by whistleblowers and they need to be supported with the understanding that society does care. We need them to do a job that most of us cannot do, and we recognize the difficulty that political pressures from certain power bases can present. Nevertheless, society should only advance, not by who we know, but by what we know, which underlies our need for transparency, and by action from the good cops. Anything less than this standard leads to greed, and that my friends is what got us into this global financial mess in the first place.


Posted by Posted by Bill Cara on November 26, 2008 03:04:37 PM | Category: Cara Today in the Market