« A sad picture of America’s purchasing power, Mon., Apr. 30, 2007, 12:53 PM | Main | Cara’s Daily Board, Wed., May 2, 2007, 7:59 AM »

May 1, 2007

Cara’s Daily Board, Tues., May 1, 2007, 8:22 AM

May Day! May Day!

Just kidding. The panic started yesterday about 2:00pm ET. Right about the time traders looked ahead a day and saw the calendar was not coming up roses. Yes, today is Pending Home Sales Day and Domestic Vehicle Sales Day in the US. Ouch.

Yesterday, after the Dow dropped quickly after 2 pm ET, to close down -58 pcts, traders saw it was a wholesale sell-off with 83 of the key 88 industry groups closing lower. Five of the ten major market sectors dropped -1 pct or more on the day. They were the most cyclical sectors: Materials (-1.7 pct), Consumer Cyclicals (-1.2 pct), Energy (-1.1 pct), Technology (-1.1 pct) and Industrials (-1.1 pct).

Surprisingly, the morning economic data, which showed more negative evidence that the US economy is slowing, did not hurt the stocks, but it immediately helped the bonds. The April Chicago PMI fell to 52.9 from 61.7, well below the 54 consensus estimate. March construction spending (+0.2 pct) and consumer spending (+0.3 pct) were also below estimates.


Economic calendar

Now there are more challenges on the econ calendar today.


Dow Jones Industrials Average

The panic set in about 2 pm ET – as soon as the moon-shot on the bonds was over. I originally took that plunge in yields as being a swing from equities to cash (ie, T-Bills), but I guess it was a switch to Bonds.

Why did this happen all morning and then stocks came off in the afternoon after the 2 pm gun went off, I don’t know. Maybe NYC traders waited til Europeans were having dinner? Do you think?


NASDAQ Composite Index

Same story here. I think the NASDAQ-heavy techs started coming off earlier when the Circuit City story was coming out, ie, Wal-Mart eating their breakfast after dropping the price tag on big screen TVs, which I say was a direct move against disappearing consumers rather than trying to put Circuit City out of business.


Asia-Pacific indices

Except for Shanghai (again), all red arrows in this region.


European indices

Negative trading early today.



$USD Index

The $USD looks soft here.


U.S. Treasury Bond Jun. 2007 contract


NYMEX Oil Jun. 2007 contract

The e-Mini Jun-07 oil contracts are at 65.575, which is -0.725 down from this time yesterday. The oil market is spiking up and down, which keeps the hedge traders on pins and needles.

I wonder how the death of Iraq’s Al-Qaeda leader will impact this market?



Gold spot chart

This morning, spot gold is at 678.33, about unchanged from yesterday at this time, but possibly headed a bit lower today.


Silver spot chart

Spot silver is at 13.41, which is down -6 from this time yesterday morning.


Platinum spot chart

Spot platinum is at 1285, which is up +7 from this time yesterday and +10 from Friday am.


Palladium spot chart

Spot palladium is trading between 366-368.50 this morning, which is unchanged from yesterday and from Friday morning. I note the media negativism re palladium vs platinum, but the palladium price is not dropping, which makes me think somebody is being deceptive.


$CRB Index

$CRB moved down from 314.20 to 312,71 at the close yesterday.

Backing and filling. Waiting.


Open Futures Contracts


Goldminer stock watch




Cara 100 Stockwatch

Here are the Cara 100 gainers yesterday.

Interactive chart of the Watch List gainers

One tough day left just a few winners (8).


Here are the top Cara 100 losers for yesterday.

Interactive chart of the top 12 Watch List losers (Interactive link)

There were 7 stocks of the Cara 100 yesterday that hit 52-week intra-day highs and none that hit lows.


Here are the interactive charts of up to a dozen stocks with (unsmoothed) RSI-7 above 70 and below 30, from “Chris”:

RSI-7 > 70 (7)

RSI-7 < 30 (8)

There are now 8 Cara 100 Company stocks that are below 30 on the Daily RSI-7 versus 8 above 70, using data from “Chris” – which he takes from BillCara2.com.

That’s what happens with a sell-off the prior day.

Now the task is to look at the charts of the stocks that are leading to the downside. Are they in trouble now or have they already been weak?

Also, we define the Distribution Zone (DZ) as when the price series data is above 70-70-70 for the Monthly-Weekly-Daily RSI-7, but a basic SELL ALERT is triggered when the Daily Relative Strength Index (7 period) falls below 70.

Obviously I also look at other indicators like MACD and STOCHASTICS and the technical indicators of the stocks of that company’s peer group before making final decisions.

But the lesson to be learned today is that every chart tells you a different story.

Look at this chart of the DAILY price series of the $USD, for example. One look and you have a certain impression, right? Cycle peak is 85.43.

Then look at the same chart for the WEEKLY and you’ll see a different picture. This is a WAVE and the Daily is a ripple. The cycle peak was 92.63 in 4Q05, and the 85.43 cycle top was actually the third one in a Bear for the $USD.

The lesson here is that long-term price data is more important than short-term data. You don’t want to be buying a ripple, only to discover to your shock the wave is crashing down upon you.


So, when I say that in a Bear market, I will occasionally buy a security, I usually call it a short-term trade. But I often don’t know whether that ripple advances and becomes a wave, like last July when I gave you about 20 tech stocks at the very bottom of the cycle. I called it a short-term trade because I had figured (as many of you know) that the broad market had topped out on or about May 10 (after the FOMC announcement) and the Bear market had begun.

But then came Goldman Sachs to the White House for discussions about a new Treasury Secretary and a new head trader for Bernanke’s Fed. Paulson, the kid who was born in Palm Beach and raised on a country estate in Illinois, understands money. He always wanted to print his own, and I guess he got to do that on June 28, 2006, his first day on the job.

How little did I suspect that Paulson would try to follow Bernanke with his own helicopter, and the money pump just went into fifth gear at that point. The broad market took off one more time and, after we saw that the July rally was for real (about Sep-Oct when those techs ought to have died), so too did Gold because “Gold Knows”.

The world is becoming an enlightened place. It’s getting harder for the Bernanke’s and Paulson’s of the world to pull the wool over our eyes.


Here are the current Cara 100 RSI-7 values, sorted by highest and lowest, first by Daily values and then by Monthly, prepared by “David” using TC2007 (Worden) [based on Welles Wilder smoothing], which is slightly different than the RSI-7 formula used by “Chris”.



Here are the stocks in the Cara 100 trading at extreme values:


In Focus



Wall Street upgrade(s)

Wall Street recent downgrades

There are various sources for up/down grades by broker-dealers. One is at Briefing.com. Traders ought to check everyday for ratings changes.


Have a great day. I’m looking to spend some time on a manuscript.

Btw, it's not a housing/mortgage/automobile industry crisis. It's a credit balloon popping.


Posted by Posted by Bill Cara on May 1, 2007 08:22:44 AM | Category: Cara's Bull Board

Discourse

Deficit Attention Syndrome / Contrary Investor

one of the best pieces i´ve seen about the deficit. excellent!

http://www.contraryinvestor.com/mo.htm

make sure you get the comment from paulsen at the end of the report....

Posted by: jmf [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 8:29 AM [link]

may day... :-)!

ValueLine Index, Median of Estimated P/E Ratios

compare this to the daily “cheap market” spin/talk

http://immobilienblasen.blogspot.com/

Posted by: jmf [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 8:30 AM [link]

Posted by: EJStockman [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 8:48 AM [link]

Interactive Brokers IPO article.

http://tinyurl.com/2ngc7g

IB will join the Cara 100 after listing. I have no comment on a price to submit at the auction.

Posted by: Bill Cara [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 9:39 AM [link]

taking positions in sds and dxd...

Posted by: 2nd_ave [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 10:05 AM [link]

My miners are getting ripped. Looking at GDX, etf gold miner, 7.5% to get to 2/27 low...that much more to go and it's not much fun. Using a weekly chart on this index, a top was fairly obvious...jumping in-out-in not a well oiled habit of mine. Holding for now, assuming that price is distorted by leverage and what is happening with the gold price. Price chart on eem and my preference, ILF/latin america, has the upper ground which gives me the hope that despite the selling of gold that we hear about by the central banks demand will remain strong. How are others handling their gold mining positions?

Posted by: jasper [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 10:10 AM [link]

2dave-

MarkM KMart Knockoff Crystal Ball apparently now working on clear days too. :)

Posted by: MarkM [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 10:14 AM [link]

Jasper - For one, I'm a fair-weather friend of junior miners (indeed of all stocks) if there's enough trading volume to avoid slippage. UXG went on sale this morning, and I got out; will try to buy back in lower ... KRY allows this, and GRZ to a lesser extent.

Of course, the problem is keeping your eye on the ball while you're out, and hoping the stock bases, turns up and encourages entry before it takes its next lurch skyward. Not easy ...

Posted by: Jock [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 10:27 AM [link]

AND HERE COME THE GLOBETROTTERS!

t4k

Posted by: trade4keeps [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 10:33 AM [link]

Does any reader know enough to make sense of KRY's drilling results reported above. Seems like just a few "red blotches" (apparently = high gold/ton concentrations) added so far from of this drilling.

Seems that there are many more holes to be reported than already reported.

The market didn't seem impressed, since the stock went north for a few minutes, then came back to earth.

Any thoughts from a better informed reader?

Posted by: Jock [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 10:38 AM [link]

t4k, lol. Kinda funny how that always happens. The tepid reaction to the ISM and woeful pending home sales are telling, however.

Posted by: number2son [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 10:40 AM [link]

Jock, given the drubbing meted out to miners today, I'd consider KRY's behavior a major victory.

Don't jinx it, man. ;)

Posted by: number2son [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 10:41 AM [link]

Jasper/Jock:


I too am away from the screen intermittently. Taking a page from someone else's book posted earlier this week, I sell stop what ever is appropriate ( for me, currently, -5% + -1x ATR) and when away, and buy stop at 3 ATR from last trade.

Posted by: RobBoss [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 10:47 AM [link]

Re Interactive Brokers IPO, since this is an Open IPO, you can submit an indication of interest outside of the "expected to price" range of $23-27. I understand that irrespective of your indication, you will receive the shares at the price the IPO is priced. Since the pricing of the IPO is not going to be materially affected by high indications from small fries like us, if you really want an allocation, you should indicate a very high amount, e.g. $35. This way, your chances of receiving an allocation are greater.

Posted by: jragusa [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 11:13 AM [link]

GLD recovering..?
http://www.kitco.com/charts/livegold.html

UXG still on sale around 5:60

Posted by: JogyP [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 11:21 AM [link]

JogyP, UXG will not recover until I sell.

I'll be sure to let everyone know when it's safe to buy again.

Posted by: number2son [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 11:29 AM [link]

Did someone say credit balloon?

http://tinyurl.com/2rfqlh

Posted by: tremendous11 [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 11:33 AM [link]

number2son,
I'm sure you're not alone in that club. I myself have been a member for more than 20 years.

Fred

Posted by: lovesaves [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 11:49 AM [link]

number2son, whenever I buy UXG, it goes up 6 -7% in the next 2 days.
2nd_ave, are you still in BMD. Thinking of taking a position here.

Posted by: JogyP [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 11:51 AM [link]

Same for me folks!
If you use my UXG position, it's now going to skyrocket, keep an eye out......
And my results are far better. When I sell any stock in question, it does double digits.

Posted by: Craig [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 12:03 PM [link]

t4k-

Patience! The Boys still have to TRY to squeeze a few extra dollars.

Seriously, VERY short leash with this and only toe in water. This is a blow-ffy kind of market and if they can put the screws on AMZN like they did they can do wonders here too.

Posted by: MarkM [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 12:08 PM [link]

MarkM,

Sometimes I don't need a crystal ball to tell me things have to go the other way ;).

Posted by: 2nd_ave [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 12:12 PM [link]

2dave-

Touche!

Posted by: MarkM [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 12:40 PM [link]

Chavez announced he wants to pull VZ out of the World Bank and IMF. The IMF lacks business because countries don't want to borrow from them.

Per BBC, Chavez also is taking control of refineries owned by XOM, COP, CVX, BP, TOT, STO - and is haggling on price.

His message is: we don't NEED these western institutions. Chavez, China, India etc. are driving change (lurchingly, uncertainly). The west is reacting, with BUSH doing what he can to undermine international law (Kyoto, Iraq, Guantanamo). Why would "the world's sheriff" want to say the law doesn't count?

The post-WW2 international framework seems to be unravelling. How will this affect traders? What will emerge in its place?

Posted by: Jock [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 12:55 PM [link]

With Rupert Murdoch buying Dow Jones, Bill's "stock" also appreciated a great deal today. The insane sell side noise is about to become deafening.

If you thought CNBC was bad, you haven't seen anything yet. Imagine Dow Jones with that Fox N' Friends flair for facts.

What will they think of next?

Posted by: Craig [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 1:32 PM [link]

I may bore the board with my process notes. Bottom line I'm persevering as my own retirement asset mgr, and hoping to learn whether or not this is a bad idea to be handling this account on my own. For me it's not entertainment or sport...not that those are bad reasons to be at the biggest casino game in the world. Maybe there are others who relate to my situation.

My account is down 2.7% from its high last week of 7.6%ytd. Each point is such tough real estate that I grunt that much more. Only 70% in equities, with rest in cash.

My wife, each week, tabulates how this "retirement nest egg" is faring in comparison to the the russell 3000. She notes that I've strayed from the original playbook where I hold only etfs, a mix of broad and focused. A relevant strength software program did remarkably well but, now, I'm afraid that the easy money has been had. I do miss this strategy which was so so much easier.

Earlier in the year I signed up with a premium news letter for stock and etf alerts where entries are done with close attention to risk reward. A lot of work to stay close to the computer screen and nimble is required to play the alerts. Their win ratio is 27-9 but it's not adding to my account. A pattern is that the longs increase just as the market corrects and then they are taken off for safety. 20 positions is considered fully invested. After 4 months, 9 positions on average at a time. Thus, the provider does show caution. But failure to sell immediately has left me with some large losses and the expected use of etfs have not materialized.

My attention and eyeball time has substantially moved to Bill's website. I'm hoping that I can find a fit that allows a portion of my account to go to stocks where it's more of an investment with longer hold times and computer time is mostly a time limited drill. Meanwhile, Bill has helped me to carve out some ground north of cost.

PM/mostly gold positions, 30percent of account, as a whole, are actually pretty good... gfi:5.6%; gdx:-1.84; grz:178; slv: -.65; slw: 18.2; uxg 37.59; wgdf: -2.71; eza: 7.43....the metal itself is showing the bigger lost..gld:-2.69. Due to my large exposure in this asset class, though, a move down is really felt.

Every trade needs an exit, so I can not expect to stay in these positions forever. I, like others I suppose, read this website religiously to learn when to exit...which for me is related to rotation rather than trading in and out.

Re Interactive Brokers, I've followed ipo's to come to believe that whenever ipo's are priced out of the initial range the odds increase that this is healthy for the longer term picture. I'll try to take a small position in this ipo, dutch auction style, via Fidelity the day before its general offering. I'm told that if I show interest at the top of the new range,31, that I will automatically have some shares allocated and pay at a lower price if that is where it is eventually priced.

Posted by: jasper [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 1:36 PM [link]

Soon it will be King Hugo of VN and King Rupert of Wall St. Does sound exotic. Just think you will now be able to get all your daily financial news from the Sun and News of the World in London.

Posted by: Horatio [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 1:39 PM [link]

Jasper -

Overtarding & impatience are the two risks I perceive from your post in your quest to invest your retirement savings. Although you shouldn't be loth to act quickly when opportunity knocks, I sense that too frequent (weekly) benchmarking and over-active trading may divert you from the objective of building substantial long-term performance at limited risk (esp. with retirement money for which you may feel somewhat higher risk aversion as I do). However thoughtful Bill's analysis and the board's discussions may be (as opposed to the constant promotional machine of CNBC et co.), we all run the risk of falling in the myopic trap of day-to-day pronouncements that run contrary to retirement wealth building. Beyond his astute reading of the tea leaves, Bill reminds his readers that patience and discipline are foremost virtues for the investor. So, in your shoes (if you are only playing with what I call restricted money), think longer term with a thorough, well-balanced and diversified watchlist of asset classes, stocks, ETFs, bonds or whatever you are interested in, and prepare to build your positions in time. Most of all, you should strive to make decisions with which you can live even if your selections cross a tough patch. Finally, I am surprised that your are so heavy into gold (or any single sector) outside of a trading/spec account. It only takes FCBs a push of the button to make you lose too much sleep IMO.

JML

Posted by: Jumble [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 2:15 PM [link]

I've been patiently waiting for something good to happen with GG, MDG and HMY and have considered selling. The idea is to avoid the drop that these will experience if the broad market heads south. But today, I noted that the RSI 14 for GG is about 37 and for MDG is about 39. Anyone have an opinion about whether this is a useful indicator to hold?

Posted by: allen [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 2:15 PM [link]

I was just checking out Doug Casey's site (via Bullionvault.com) and notice that he feels that junior gold co's have vast appreciation potential in this stage of the market. He offers a service for around $1100 for 3 months or $4500 per year to spot special situations in these pm shares and give trading alerts. I don't have that kind of money, and I would not want to take a chance at such a high price, but the implication would seem to be that when one pays such a price, the rewards are assumed to be commensurate. It occured to me that Bill's project of assembling a database on small mining co's would be just as good and also free or minimal cost. Does anyone have experience with the type of proposal that Casey is offering? Any thoughts?

Posted by: aucourant [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 2:24 PM [link]

For the nervous gold bugs, I post (again?) some interesting views from Lee Wheeler at Wall Street Examiner.

http://tinyurl.com/2la2ds
http://tinyurl.com/34798d

JML

Posted by: Jumble [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 2:40 PM [link]

Allen - I believe GG was removed from the Cara 100 recently - due to the GLG acquisition and the ensuing shareholder's rights battle. I believe of the senior miners, Bill prefers KGC but I would definitely refer to his posts of course before taking action. Hope this helps.

Posted by: rusticuf [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 2:42 PM [link]

Jumble,


Thanks so much for your thoughtful response and well worth a re-read. Out of impatience I've strayed from the well diversified, slow and steady, and no big bets. Too stressful and at some point stress leads to bad decisions. Thanks Again!

Posted by: jasper [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 2:44 PM [link]

Jasper and others,

Start thinking like an old bull. Take your time and you'll get them all. But charging around here and there will just tire you out.

Its days like this where I know most of you appreciate the wise advice you get from successful and patient advisors.

I have stayed away from recommending stocks other than as examples for educational purposes. I want this blog to remain a site for education, information and facilitation from my side and discussion on yours. That way over time, we'll all be better served.

Recall my words in a recent WIR, trading is hard. I like to say that if trading was easy, where we just sat around hitting the 'easy' button to make money, there would be no farmers, steelworkers and factory workers doing the real work.

Trading successfully is a life skill that has to be developed over time. Some people pick it up quickly and others do not. However, I think the harder you work at it, the quicker success will come to you. And once you reach a point where you think you know it all, you realize there is more to learn.

I never stop learning, and I think all of you will agree that I work pretty hard at it. By my showing you how much commitment I have, I hope that I am setting an example to younger people.

Yes, if you love trading as I do, this isn't work, but it is commitment.

Posted by: Bill Cara [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 3:01 PM [link]

Jasper -

In all honesty, it is easier to preach patience & stress control than practice it. Just limit it to the money you can afford to lose (but your ulcers will still prove that you hate to and your spouse will aptly remind you of your reckless behavior at the bottom when you peer into the abyss).

JML

Posted by: Jumble [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 3:03 PM [link]

Bill and Jumble,

I have to really have a face to face talk. I have to know what kind of investing that I am comfortable in pursuing. I think that I get hooked by approaches that fall outside of my comfort area and I fail to know when I am leaving my original turf. I'm not sure if my fascination can lead me to the necessary skill acquisition if nimble is required. My comfort is with top down investing, asset rotation, a routine that may demand a few hrs a day but not constant screen viewing. I want to hang out and learn from Bill and fellow posters but not go beyond what I regard as limitations. As a self directed mgr of my retirement account I think one such limitation is that it is distracting, if not dangerous, for me to be on the same field with others who have different goals and are learning what may be different skills. My determination is that I have this un-dying conviction that I can do a much better job than the Fidelity Advisor or the typical wrap account manager.

Jumble....interesting articles on the xau/gold ratio. Written a few weeks back when folks probably felt rosier. Still, strikes me as informative for future decision making. Thanks.


Posted by: jasper [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 3:49 PM [link]

JogyP: Yes, this would be a good time to open a position in BMD. I'm adding myself, and hope to finish accumulating a significant position by this summer, which is when they will be doing the bulk of their business. If you Google "Birch Mountain" you can find a couple of old analysts' reports from '05 and '06 with target prices between 8 and 12.

Posted by: 2nd_ave [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 3:49 PM [link]

What a crappy day. I seem to be in that zone again, where every stock I short heads up and every stock I buy goes down.

[Sigh]

Posted by: number2son [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 3:52 PM [link]

Hi All,

I'm trying to buy into the Interactive Broker IPO and am not sure how this conditional offer stuff works. If I put an order to buy X amount of shares at $31 ( the price range is expected to be 27-31) and what if the actual price is $27 ? Will I get my shares at $27 or $31 ?

Posted by: TheAdonis [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 3:57 PM [link]

BMD is my only long, btw. Other than that, I'm just waiting for the next "red sky in the morning".

Posted by: 2nd_ave [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 3:59 PM [link]

n2son,

You mentioned being able to see the Maze from your office. Is this what traffic looks like when you head home: http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/object/article?o=0&f=/c/a/2007/05/01/BAGHNPIQ5I5.DTL

Posted by: 2nd_ave [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 4:04 PM [link]

theadonis,

you are only saying the max price willing to pay, ergo, you will get the lower price

price range has changed: 27-31.

Posted by: jasper [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 4:12 PM [link]

Bill & Others:

I truly appreciate your efforts and comments ( and indulgence to newer posters/readers).

After 30+ years on the sell side I, like Jasper, am managing my own retirement funds. Net Results - OK, ups and downs, but rarely intellectually unstimulated or unchallenged - particularly on this site.

This is my serious money that I will need to grow in order to maintain and improve my lifestyle. Sometimes stressful (not market movement, but questioning my own judgement). Nonetheless,far less stressful than watching some MF (you know I mean Mutual Mund) manager or stock broker erode my net worth (I can do that just fine by myself, thank you, without those fees and commisions.)

I'll close with a question for the crowd: The DOW volume today was one of the lowest in several years. As I write this the DJII was up about 1/2% with roughly 55% of the average EMA(50) volume.

Is this light volume something primarily attributable to the Asian holidays? I think I will continue to research some selected Puts (am running through Bills RSI>70 extreme level stocks for candidates.

Posted by: RobBoss [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 4:23 PM [link]

jasper,

Maybe you just have the wrong Fidelity advisor.

I can say in total honesty that there were many clients I worked with over the years that I was not suited for. Some of the advice I gave was not effective for them either.

This is the one area of the sell-side that really needs work. It is a matter of fact that both the clients and the advisors need better self-assessment and in some cases testing. Then the firms ought to do a better job mixing and matching client to advisor on a compatibility basis. The problem, of course, is that if a salesperson's income depends on retaining a particular client, common sense usually goes out the window.

A lesson I learned from a client I once had when working for a major portfolio manager I'll never forget. The client turned over $x for discretionary management with a proviso that a relatively small percentage be used for high-risk instruments. Less than a week later, I tripled that not-so-small holding in options. The client, who I kept informed because I was trying to teach him the options market, then called to tell me to move it all into his "conservative" account. He was a young psychiatrist who apparently knew himself pretty well. He told me that watching those options move in price had taken control of his professional life and he no longer wanted any such distractions.

What I learned at that point was that it's not just financial success (maybe you'll call it greed) that drives people.

If advisors or managers are going to work with people they will have to understand them, and vice versa. What I try to do with this blog is teach enough to some people to help them better communicate to their advisors, and maybe even to talk to their advisor's boss to see if there might not be a better fit. Rather than lose a client, every sell-side firm would like to make the switch to a new advisor.

And, of course, some of you will be picking up enough education and information here to set you going on an independent route. After all, it's your capital and nobody is going to be more concerned about it than you.

One of the people I hired once had been the president of the Toronto Stock Exchange's floor traders association back when the TSX had a physical floor. A few years later I introduced him to a day trading firm to give some words of experience. He told them: "You might start by trading hundreds and not thousands".

Most of us want to try to do too much. It's a natural trait. But if we relax, and let the market take the lead, some of us ought to choose a slow dance and let others try something faster.

It's difficult days like these where traders can learn the most. When Bull markets are moving fast, even turkeys fly like eagles. Everybody thinks they are an eagle, but deep down we all know the truth.

Posted by: Bill Cara [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 4:33 PM [link]

Hey, thanks a bunch 2ndAve. Things weren't bad enough today with the market going all irrational on me, you had to provide a picture of what I'll be facing in a few hours. ;)


Posted by: number2son [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 4:35 PM [link]

Jasper,

From the sounds of it, you may be paying too close attention to the small details and not enough to the larger picture (seeing the forest for the trees, etc..). You should focus more of your efforts at the end goal, which is retirement in your case. I work for a large bank and I manage assets for people (mostly discretionary accounts), so I deal with this on a daily basis. Believe me, your concern is not uncommon.

Truthfully, most of your performance comes from asset allocation, and less so from actual stock picking. You can reference many studies out there, but the Brinson study is probably the most well known, where it was shown that about 77% of your return comes from AA (being invested in the right area). Security selection accounted for about 10% or so (there are other smaller factors as well). I guess what I am trying to get at is that you need to remain focused on having the proper allocation at the right time and less so on what your next stock pick will be.

I believe what Bill and others graciously provide here on this forum is the tools to succeed for that remaining 10% or so of your return as well as for smaller speculative pools of money. You mentioned that you had a plan early on and have deviated from it and noted a larger exposure to metals. Jumble hit the nail right on the head-you will be much better off with a well-balanced and well-diversified portfolio long term. It's easy to preach it, but far more difficult to practice it.

Keeping yourself informed of world markets and economic factors can help you determine how much to allocate to large cap, mid/small cap, international, etc... Once you have that, use Bill's tools to help you find the securities that will benefit most from those economic factors (most of which he already does).

Kind of a long rant, but keep the faith brother. Keeping informed of your finances and retirement is one of the best things you can do for yourself in terms of education and well being.

Posted by: ricej11 [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 5:10 PM [link]

Nasdaq up but declining volume was 1.5X advancing volume.

Posted by: Leisa [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 5:56 PM [link]

Greetings from Canada, I am reading the IBIPO Auction System (Interactive Brokers IPO) and from their web site it states Due to Canadian legal restrictions, residents of Canada may not bid in an IBIPO Auction. Any ways around this restriction.

Posted by: trader [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 8:00 PM [link]

Interactive Brokers (IBKR) vs Etrade (ETFC)

http://www.ipohome.com/common/ipoprofile.asp?ticker=ibkr
http://finance.yahoo.com/q/is?s=ETFC&annual

Summary:
Market cap
ETFC - 9.58 B
IBKR - 10.1 B (27-31 Price Range)

2006 Revenue
ETFC - 2.4
IBKR - 1.62

2006 Net Income
ETFC - 628 M
IBKR - 734 M
I know there are other factors to compare, but if IBKR goes too high from the IPO range, ETFC may go up in sympathy.

Posted by: JogyP [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 8:01 PM [link]

Aucourant- re: Doug Casey

Doug Casey is a gold bug who did well near the top of gold bubble in the late 70's. I read his "Crisis Investing" book and remember watching him on Donahue promoting hard assets as the sure way to create the millionaires of the future, while the poor suckers left holding paper assets would find their holdings lose value as the governement printing presses did their thing.

People who followed his advice at the time lost their collective shirts. I liked what he said, but fortuneately as a college student, I didn't have any money to invest at the time.

He may ultimately be right, but his timing was poor. I'm surprised that he is still around. I consider him like Howard Ruff or Joseph Granville- guys who had their moments, but fell from the limelight when their inflexible strategies no longer worked.

I can't imagine paying $4500 annually for his advice. I would feel much more comfortable (at any price)with Bill's choices of junior golds, if and only if you felt the need to invest in junior golds based on the factors often discussed in this blog.

Just check out this thread for some great investment advice. Diversify. And I really like Bills' AZ and DZ methodogy. A stock in the AZ may not go up, but so far my own results with this method has been very good, and I have the peace of mind knowing that I won't overpay for a stock.

Posted by: Klingon288 [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 8:07 PM [link]

Coffee futures at a buck a pound. This must be good for SBUX. Even Schultz has commented in the past that coffee prices make a difference in their bottom line.

Posted by: stktrader [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 8:26 PM [link]

Klingon288

Thanks for your lowdown on Casey! I wasn't planning to plonk down $4500, but I was kind of tempted by another offer at $79/3 mo. Now I'm not. I trust Bill's methodology and instincts more than any other, as my purchases reflect--SLW,GLD,KRI,KGC, as well as Sprott's MLY. I have been late getting into some of these because I find they rocket up sometimes after Bill mentions them and my reluctance to chase them means I wait too long and pay too much. When a stock is on a tear, it's hard to wait for the RSI to be below 30. I'm not sure how to handle this!

Has anyone looked at Maudore Minerals (MA0.V)? It was recommended by Jay Taylor.

Posted by: aucourant [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 8:28 PM [link]

n2son-in my opinion, except for the traffic, you reside in one of the best places to live on this planet...i wouldn't trade the bay area for anything else.

Posted by: 2nd_ave [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 8:48 PM [link]

Hi Bill, Thanks for great and valuable site and all the incredible work you do.
About the Bahamas Fund. How does a Canadian get money in..and out?
Was in Nassau 2 weeks ago and went to Matisse for dinner hoping to recognise you from your pic. No luck. Are you going to any AGM's in Toronto? Tomorow there's YRI and FRG. S on May 24.
Anyways love Bahamas and your fund may give me an opportunity to visit.

Posted by: advanced [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 9:11 PM [link]

Some of you guys make it impossible for me not to respond.

Advanced, the last two times I was in Nassau I left directly from there to the airport. My office used to be right beside them. My registered office is a block away. It is in my opinion the best rstaurant of the Bahamas for a business lunch.

Yes, everybody will have a chance to visit me, and I will help with all your decisions re Bahamas, etc, objectively of course because I would not want a person to return home disappointed. Alas, there is advertising everywhere that cannot cut the mustard.

Re Doug Casey, I have different views. He is quite controversial. The bottom line is that I support him, unlike people like him on CNBC. Look, we all have people questioning us, but Doug Casey has published many best selling books and he is a top drawer speaker wherever he goes. But he appeals to a certain audience and I would never want to stand in the way of that. His advice is like that of Kaimu (or my own).Many people don't accept it).

Doug Casey is a bit like Eric Sprott in that both invest in and sell themes. That means you must stay tuned. In time those themes change. But, the bottom line is that I like these people because they carefully think out their strategic moves versus say many of the "personalities" many of you see daily or weekly on Financial Entertainment TV.

And they both put their money where their mouth is.

Re Interactive Bokers, if you like IPO's, this will likely be a good one. More importantly the company will likely stay on the Cara Global 100 for a long time.

Today was a strange day in the market. I would be watching volume x price because I think there is lots of rotation going on.

Posted by: Bill Cara [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 9:46 PM [link]

Bill, Jumble, and Ricej11....

Soul searching day. A lot said that does resonate. Thank you.

Posted by: jasper [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 10:48 PM [link]

Re: Casey
While I wouldn't necessarily disagree with anything that was already said about Doug Casey, I do believe that his newsletter (the cheaper one) is well worth the money. The amount of fundamental analysis and due dilligence that it provides is extraordinary. He focuses on quality management, quality assets, and companies that don't give the store away (options, warrants etc). For strictly fundamental info on junior miners, its a high quality rag. But, of course, anyone with any experience will tell you that trading successfully and making good returns on a risky asset class takes a lot more than good stock picking.

The reason why Bill Cara doesn't get caught up in picking fish every day here (besides legality), is because he is trying to teach us how to fish. I used to think that I only had to be smart enough to find, or buy the "right" market analysis for whatever macro environment I believed in at the time. If only it were taht easy. After a few years of consistent effort, I have learned enough about myself as a trader to get much bettter at it. There is no quick route. Contrary to what I used to believe, there is very little, if any, superior information available. I use Casey for fundamental research. My success, great or small, is the result of using this information in a superior manner.

Posted by: schnauser [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 1, 2007 11:52 PM [link]

Bill see HW's earnings report today-home run! Havnt checked RSI, but trading at B.V. with big boyz blowing out stops within 1% of 52 W.L. (sound familiar); 20% of float short will make for one first-rate fireworks show noting how small the door is. I predict a "buy" upgrade very soon noting folks like JPMorgan initiated coverage last week. The story is no longer a pipedream, nice timing for a coal to liquids story noting another refinery went down today :)

Posted by: Rick45 [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 2, 2007 1:55 AM [link]

re: Doug Casey's newsletters. In my experience, he first recommends stock picks in the pricey newsletter,and these are months later, recommended on the cheap one. You can imagine the effect this can have on price action and how it may impact subscribers to "cheapo". Despite this "problem", some of his picks continue to soar.

Posted by: bigbri [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 2, 2007 8:02 AM [link]

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?