« Last week's huge gains in SMH wiped out, Mon., Dec. 5, 2005, 5:01 PM | Main | The sun has risen, Tues., Dec. 6, 2005, 8:36 AM »
December 5, 2005
Goldminer stocks are lagging the bullion, Mon., Dec. 5, 2005, 5:47 PM
An interesting phenomenon is happening to precious metal stocks. A sell-off in many North American issues has continued a second day, running opposite to the higher move in bullion.
I'll try to figure this one out.
Clearly Friday and Monday were down days in the equity market, caused by profit taking among the leaders, and gold and silver stocks have been leaders for sure. They have pulled back, or at least stayed flat.
And just as clearly, the bullion prices have been moving higher because there is a strong appetite around the world for precious metals, as opposed to paper money and securities. The supply of precious metals is quite limited. If central banks do not put supply onto the market, as seems to be the case lately, then the price of the bullion will have to rise, and it has.
In fact the only thing that is going to pull back precious metal prices at this point will be the satisfying of consumer demand, caused by a blow off price spike to the upside. In other words, all the buyers find a price they are prepared to pay " regardless how high that might be " and then poof, no more buyers.
Do I think this might happen? Yes, I think it is inevitable. I just don't know when.
I do know that the potential buying power is virtually unlimited. It far outstrips the potential supply.
So the size of the appetite is all that has to be measured. Do you remember the story of Tulip Mania in 17th Century Europe?
Well, gold has always been precious, and unlike tulips, which wither and die, and tulip bulbs, which can be easily grown, gold has no supply "issues". At some point there just isn't any metal to buy.
Demand is not infinite, of course, but when you look at government spending and debts today, and personal debts, and the inflated prices of assets backing up a large part of that debt, it's fair to say that demand for gold could go to extremes, if not forever.
Under the microscope this week will be the psychological $500 inflection point. Is demand for gold going to blow right past $500 or will demand pull back.
Isn't that a question better suited to cab drivers and hair dressers?

Posted by Posted by Bill Cara on December 5, 2005 05:47:30 PM | Category: Bullion , Gold , Goldminer Producers
Discourse
Bill,
I don't know what is causing the lag in the miners, but I'm pretty sure what will cause it to end -- consolidation. If the price of bullion outpaces the price of gold in the ground plus lifting costs, aggressive miners (and those forced to become aggressive because of troublesome hedges) will simply "buy" exploration. We saw a hint of that today, with Goldcorp and Iamgold acquiring smaller properties.
Posted by: josh
at
December 5, 2005 10:18 PM [link]
Guys-
Time to take some profits in GLG on the spike? Up 6% on the day . Buy it again when it settles down.
Posted by: MarkM
at
December 6, 2005 2:55 PM [link]

I have noticed this divergence a couple of times over the last few years and have a short list that I am thinking of:
1. The equity market has pulled down mining shares while gold rallied.
2. Today, the price of oil traded back above $60 and the downtrend may have reversed. Mining earnings have been negatively affected by higher energy costs in the past and may do so again.
3. There may be internal issues with some gold miners due to hedging. I wouldn't doubt that some producers have loans or hedges that are blowing up in their faces now and may affect current earnings.
4. Maybe it's simply booking gains because traders don't believe that gold will stay over $500.
This is why my core position is in the metal itself.
Just my $0.02.
Posted by: g034
at
December 5, 2005 6:14 PM [link]