« EU, forex and capital markets today, Tuesday, May 31, 2005, 6:06 AM | Main | Keeping perspective, Wed., June 1, 2005, 8:07 AM »
May 31, 2005
Cara on Cara, today, Tues., May 31, 2005, 9:27 AM
I am afraid that there are too many things going on in my personal life right now that are holding me back from writing as much or as focused as I'd like. In addition I can no longer commit to answering all mail, at least for a while.
I promise; these things are passing.
It has been your mail that has led me in recent days to make a decision to split this blog into two: (i) one for the general public, which I will try to make simpler, but also more relevant with the addition of sample portfolios and trades that I will monitor, and (ii) one for sell-side Registered Professional Advisors only, where I will invite a large number of you to participate (strictly private & confidential basis) so that together we can produce a free website/blog that will contain a solid value proposition for all advisors.
With respect to my last point, I think the public would be shocked to discover the realities of being employed as a registered representative and client advisor by a financial institution. There are some bad apples in every barrel, but the truth is that the huge majority of advisors are good people, trying to do a good job for clients.
The problem lies in the structure of the securities industry, its politics, its rules and regulations, and so forth.
The public ought to be aware that the advisor's employer, not your advisor personally, calls the shots on virtually all matters. Moreover, if the advisor attempts to stand up for his or her rights or yours they are blackballed or dismissed.
As a case in point, I never would have been allowed by my colleagues, or by regulators, to write some things I do in this blog. That's not because there are any untruths, but exactly the opposite; it is the truth.
I'm not going to get into a debate as to what is truth; we all recognize it when we see it. As in war, we all know the first casualty is truth, so too has the capital markets been turned into a fiction by those who think they can control it.
The one inescapable fact in capital markets, which were taken control of some seventy years ago by the sell-side financial institutions, is that the public is not told the truth, but a carefully spun version of it.
I see it, but so too does at least one million registered advisors in North America. I get letters all the time that say something like, please don't let my bank know, but what you write about is so true, and I cannot do a thing about it.
I'm not going to get into these issues today because of the reasons I have given you, but I do hope that individual registered reps, and even the smaller independent firms, do contact me privately at my personal mail (carabill at rogers.com) and tell me you'd like to be involved in helping me develop a separate private blog that will support the registered advisor of public clients.
Together, we can bring about a change in the way the public is treated, which is important to me, and I think to you. In fact, all of you.
Posted by Posted by Bill Cara on May 31, 2005 09:28:07 AM | Category: Cara re: Cara
Discourse
I am very disappointed that I will be relegated to the "simple" public domain and won't have access to your deeper insights.
Posted by: R. James at May 31, 2005 1:54 PM [link]
Sorry to read your post, Bill. This means that non-professionals would get a diluted version of your collective wisdom, whereas many advisors will still not comment (i.e. contribute) to the other blog for fear of losing their shield of anonymity. If their anonymity is preserved, why can't we get their comments on a single version of your blog?
Posted by: Kaushik at May 31, 2005 2:12 PM [link]
What a shame. A sanitized version for the masses? Great. Will it still be a blog or another market letter put out by "professionals" to buy their stocks du jour. I thank you for your past insights and wish you the best of the future.
Posted by: fred9476 at May 31, 2005 5:36 PM [link]
I have to say I am kind of bent on this decision, it's not the Cara I've come to know. Maybe it's not clear to me, but this is your endeavor, and you do get to decide it's fate. good luck /Sergio
Posted by: Sergio at May 31, 2005 10:22 PM [link]
Think about this... doctors speak differently to doctors, but they will still tell the truth to laymen. I gather that Bill doesn't intend to leave anyone in the dark. I gather that his intentions are to provide non-professional investors with the same insight and information about the markets. He probably just doesn't want to laden the information with industry jargon. Does the typical investor understand a; breakout, resistance, consolidation, or retracement, for (a couple of easy) example(s)? Or might it be easier to understand; it's going higher, stopping here, not moving, or pulling back? I for one will be patient before passing judgement too quickly.
Posted by: RlzGain at June 1, 2005 1:40 AM [link]
Great idea Bill. Anonymity critical. Many of us are absolutely restricted from making any comment or statement of any kind in a public manner and especially on the internet.
Posted by: John at May 31, 2005 10:44 AM [link]